Coterie diapers are exceptionally soft, feeling almost pillow-like due to their material being made partially from sustainably managed wood pulp. This softness ensures easy application without the diaper curling up. Their high-end quality is comparable to organic cotton and bamboo outfits, making them a preferred choice for many.
The Honest Brand diapers, while good and frequently used, don't stand out in terms of softness or comfort. They feel like standard diapers, lacking the luxurious feel that some other brands offer. Honest has softer flaps but a rougher lining than Coterie.
Coterie diapers stand out for being free from chlorine bleach, fragrances, dyes, latex, and cruelty-free testing. They are also free of many other questionable ingredients like parabens, phthalates, heavy metals, and alcohol to avoid harmful skin reactions. They use third-party labs to verify their "clean" claims, and that adds credibility to their product. Their website also provides a toxicity report that is available for download, which helps us to learn what these diapers are made of.
The Honest Brand emphasizes the cleanliness of their diapers and has a "NO List" of over 2,500 chemicals they avoid, including phthalates, parabens, and animal cruelty. For an odor inhibitor, Honest uses citrus extract. However, the complete list isn't readily available, which makes it harder for parents to verify their claims.
Honest diapers have two layers: an absorbent inner layer that absorbs urine and a waterproof outer layer that prevents moisture from leaking through the diapers. However, Honest diapers can only hold urine for up to 10 hours.
Coterie focuses on sustainability with a direct-to-consumer (DTC) model reducing the production line's environmental impact. Their diapers are made from 25% plant-based materials sourced from sustainably managed forests, and some components are biodegradable. First, we need to acknowledge that complete biodegradability isn't possible for disposable diapers, they're transparent about their product.
Honest highlights its sustainability by stating it uses wood from sustainably managed pine and spruce trees in Scandinavia for the core of its diapers, however, their transparency is questionable because they don't provide further details.
Coterie is offering comparatively more features in the diaper quality. They start from size Newborn to size 6. And Pants for 14-24 lbs (3T), 20-32 lbs (4T), 27-38 lbs (5T), and over 33-63 lbs (6T). They have more weight-specific options in the Pants than Honest.
They have daytime diapers available from size N to 7, and overnight diapers from size 3 to 6. This means that Honest diapers cater to babies with different weights, offering more options than Coterie. And Training Pants for up to 34 lbs (2T-3T), 32-40 lbs (3T-4T), and 38+ lbs (5T-6T). Honest takes the lead in this category by offering a wide variety of sizes and more features.
For one-time Newborns - $90.00 for 6 packs (186 total count/box) - up to $0.48 per diaper With Subscription Newborns - $85.00 for 6 packs (186 total count/box) - up to $0.45 per diaper
Purchasing from their website would be the best deal for efficient cost-per-diaper. Coterie also offers 10% off for its auto-renew subscription. And you can manage the subscription by text message. They’re also available at Walmart, Pottery Barn Kids, and Whole Foods for shopping in person.
For one-time Newborns - $12.99 for 1 pack (36 total count/box) - up to $0.36 per diaper With Subscription Newborns - $12.34 for 1 pack (36 total count/box) - up to $0.34 per diaper
These are the price points from their website. If you compare it with Amazon, the same size N $35.49 (76 diapers) up to $0.49 per diaper. If you are looking for an affordable option, purchasing from their website would give you efficient cost-per-diaper. But you can also purchase it at Target, or Walmart.
Both Diapers offer the best features on their own. Honest Diapers has standard Material, quality, absorbency, and an affordable price range. If you’re looking for a soft, sturdy, hypoallergenic diaper that helps prevent major blowouts and diaper rashes and keeps the moisture out while the baby sleeps, Coterie diapers are worth the investment. But if you compare it with Honest Diaper Prices ‘they are nice to have’.